The following is a review I posted to Amazon a few weeks back for the new Red Hot Chili Peppers album, I'm With You.
"Well, after the underwhelming, drawn out filler-fest that was Stadium Arcadium, fans were left wondering what to expect from the new album. John Frusciante's fan club were distraught to see him depart (again) and it was left to backing guitarist from the band's last tour, Josh Klinghoffer, to fill the void. The result is a more subtle guitar performance, but one that truly lets flea kick loose, making this a much better balanced album than their last and a joy from start to finish.
Things kick off in spectacular fashion with Monarchy Of Roses, a barnstorming rocker, half Warped, half disco rock. No sooner have you had chance to catch your breath that Kiedis' spoken rap melds perfectly with Flea's funky bass on Factory Of Faith, which includes an infectiously funky outro that conjures memories of the late Hillel Slovak and reminds listeners that Klinghoffer can lead from the front too.
Next comes Brendan's Death Song, the first ballad on the album. Fans have drawn comparisons with perhaps the band's most famous track, Under The Bridge. And they would be right, with the swelling guitar licks and acoustic rhythm building into a powerful chorus. By the end of the track, it's a goosebump-triggering stadium classic remeniscant of King's Of Leon's Use Somebody - and Kiedis gives a stunning vocal performance with the chorus of "yeahs" in the track's conclusion. In my opinion, this is the most powerful 5 minutes and 40 seconds of music RHCP have ever recorded - it's simply breathtaking.

No sooner have we regained our composure and wiped the tears than we're propelled back into the funk rollercoaster with Ethiopia. Flea once again drops a great bassline, and Chad Smith's inspired 7/8 beat keeps the listener on the edge. Anthony's lyrics are so-so at first, but as the groove builds they fit the jam perfectly. Midway through, we're treated to some chorus-heavy guitar washes from Klinghoffer that once again signal that he is open to the styles of Slovak as well as Frusciante, but we're soon back into farmiliar territory for the Peppers with Annie Wants A Baby, with a bassline reminiscant of "This Is The Place" but little else to get excited about. It's perhaps the weakest track on the album, but even this is a good song, if slightly underwhelming.
Of course, the Chili Peppers are at their best catching you off guard, and the album is then abruptly thrown into an explosion of uptempo funk rock with Look Around. This is sure to be a crowd favourite - Kiedis returns to his Rhythmic rapping for the second time while Klinghoffer's mixture of power and melody in the opening creates one of the best combinations between Flea and his guitarist since the Uplift Mofo Party Plan album. The chorus, for all it' simplicity, will be stuck in your head from the first listen.
Next up is lead single The Adventures Of Raindance Maggie. Again, Flea is in fine fettle, and Klinghoffer's guitar washes and Claptonesque soars in the chorus work well and suit the minimalist style that the Chili's sound best when exercising - something lost in the guitar heavy Stadium Arcadium. Kiedis is in his comfort zone, but again the chorus is catchy - "hey now, we've got to make it rain somehow" - and his scat singing in the outro is infectious. Plus, massive kudos for Chad Smith having the nerve to add cowbell after all his comparisons to Will Ferrell!
Did I Let You Know lets Flea loose with his french horn again, something we've heard sadly very little of since the Mothers Milk and Freaky Styley albums. It's subtle, and does mean we have an understated bass track here - perhaps so we can see flea play the former in live shows? Klinghoffer puts in a haunting and solid backing vocal here; forums were awash asking questions over who was singing, and even what gender they were - perhaps a slightly embarrasing testimonial for his powerful vocal range! But Klinghoffer is back to his forté in the next track, the uptempo Goodbye Hooray, which sees powerful instrumental performances from all 3 musicians. There's even room for a barrelhouse piano in the backing, and the psychedelic, trancey bridge midway through is an interesting dynamic which serves to make the closing minute, which culminates in a mindblowing rock-out ending, even more powerful.
Next is Happiness Loves Company, which is sure to be marmite to RHCP fans in the same way Cabron and the Zephyr Song were on By The Way. It's infectiously upbeat, and the prominent piano and Flea's rare appearence on backing vocals with bop-de-bop singing make it truly unlike any Pepper's song to date. It's reminiscant of Britpop, but executed much better than the butchering indie of the past decade. If ever there was a second single from the album, this would be it, and I for one really dig it.
Police Station is another Ballad, and another good performance from Klinghoffer. The piano stabs later on are strangely haunting, perhaps because it's not expected of the Peppers to use such an instrument so heavily. Not that it's a bad thing, and they meld nicely with Josh's soaring, minimalist style. Then there's Even You Brutus?, the last burst of rap on the album and a new direction for Kiedis, with him ditching the rhythmic flows for an almost-yelling contemporary 21st century style. I was unsure of it at first - worried, even, that the rap style which made Kiedis unique was going to be lost in favour of the mainstream. But on closer inspection, it's pulled off effortlessly and combines so well with the piano backing that what starts as a suprising departure from convention becomes farmiliar and impressive very quickly.
Into the album's closing strait, and first there's Meet Me At The Corner. It's very minimal stuff, with Kiedis again leading from the front. The lyrics are suprisingly introspective. It will never be a fan's first choice, but it's solid with another pleasant Guitar and backing vocal performance from Klinghoffer. Finally, there's Dance Dance Dance, which perhaps makes the most of the much-touted but little-exploited claims of an afro-pop influence on the album. The drum beat chugs along nicely, with Flea putting in one final shift before the close of the Album. Kiedis' initially grating orders of "Dance! Dance! Dance! Dance!" become more and more infectious as more and more people join in with the song's progression. There's even room for one more sweet bridge from Klinghoffer, although it's over too soon. It's one of those "end of a party songs" - not too taxing for tired revellers, but upbeat enough to convince folks to keep on going. And with that the album recedes into the mist, and you're left feeling like the Peppers are truly starting fresh.
In conclusion, this album is, musically, flawless. Flea has perhaps not been as prominent on a RHCP album perhaps since at least Californication, perhaps Blood Sugar Sex Magik. Josh Klinghoffer, for all the gripes and disguisting scapegoating of a sizable number of so called "fans" who can't accept the departure of John Frusciante, proves himself time and time again, and yet is still subtle enough to let his band members shine instead of stealing the spotlight. Even so, he finds the space to put in a performance on Brendan's Death Song which could push Under The Bridge as one of the most iconic tracks RHCP have ever produced. Chad Smith is incredibly technical on the album, perhaps it's unsung hero who keeps everything rolling and has enough flourishes to grab the listener's attention throughout. Kiedis is the cherry on top, with a vocal ability that continually improves with each new album - again, listen to the stunning high notes at the end of Brendan's Death Song for proof that he is becoming a truly powerful singer. We also see an increased prominence of his famous spoken rap, as well as a new take in Even You Brutus?, which wraps up a solid performance all round from the band.
So I for one am comfortable to declare this the best Red Hot Chili Peppers album since Blood Sugar Sex Magik. There isn't a track on here that truly dissapoints, and you'll soon have your own favourites. Early fans will love Factory Of Faith, Goodbye Hooray and Look Around, while those who admire their contemporary work will love Police Station, Happiness Loves Company and Brendan's Death Song. Experimenters will dig Ethiopia, The Adventures Of Raindance Maggie and Monarchy Of Roses. So sit back and enjoy. The artwork is most certainly apt - you'll be left wanting a repeat prescription when the bug bites you. "
I gave it 5 stars. Hope you can see why. :)